All the Best Long Island Theater Shows, Musicals and More

Theater shows on Long Island

Find events from Jun 10 to Jan 1 in your neighborhood

On or off Broadway theater shows, listings of plays, musicals, opera, performance art, and so much more

Post an Event

Wednesday Oct. 15, 2025

Haunted Theaters of Broadway

12:30 – 1:45 pm

The Haunted Theaters of Broadway

Classes
Free

Emma Clark LibrarySetauket

Thursday Oct. 16

StagingGatsbyCalendarImage

6 – 8 pm

Staging Gatsby: Excerpts from “These Gilded Souls, A Jazz Age Ghost Story”

Free
Theater

The Long Island MuseumStony Brook

Friday Oct. 17

Screenshot

7:30 – 9:30 pm

Playwrights’ Theatre of East Hampton at LTV Studios Presents ‘Be My Baby’

Theater

LTV StudiosWainscott

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Saturday Oct. 18

Oct 18 La Sonnambula

1 – 4:30 pm

THE MET: LIVE IN HD—LA SONNAMBULA

Film
Theater

Guild HallEast Hampton

Image-empty-state

7:30 – 9:30 pm

Playwrights Theater of East Hampton at LTV Studios Presents Rhinoceros

Theater

LTV StudiosWainscott

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Sunday Oct. 19

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Monday Oct. 20

7 – 11 pm

Gateway’s Haunted Playhouse

The Gateway PACSCBellport

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Tuesday Oct. 21

7 – 11 pm

Gateway’s Haunted Playhouse

The Gateway PACSCBellport

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Wednesday Oct. 22

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Thursday Oct. 23

b&j2025

8 – 10 pm

BENNY & THE JETTS

BACCA Arts CenterLindenhurst

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Friday Oct. 24

Screenshot 2025-10-13 at 5.04.57 PM

11 am – 8 pm

Tabernacle Fair: Immersive Exhibit | Family Fun | Korean Food Festival

Ages: All
Community
Expo
Family

MahanaimHuntington

Oct 24 Inter Alia

7 – 9 pm

NATIONAL THEATRE LIVE: INTER ALIA

Theater

Guild HallEast Hampton

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Saturday Oct. 25

lif-calendar-Uncle-Vlad’s-Pumpkin-Patch-2025-10

11 am

Uncle Vlad’s Pumpkin Patch

Ages: 3 – 12
Attractions
Family
Halloween

Long Island Children’s MuseumGarden City

Screenshot 2025-10-13 at 5.04.57 PM

11 am – 8 pm

Tabernacle Fair: Immersive Exhibit | Family Fun | Korean Food Festival

Ages: All
Community
Expo
Family

MahanaimHuntington

lif-calendar-Uncle-Vlad’s-Pumpkin-Patch-2025-10

1 pm

Uncle Vlad’s Pumpkin Patch

Ages: 3 – 12
Attractions
Family
Halloween

Long Island Children’s MuseumGarden City

3 – 5 pm

Diwali Celebration

Jeanne Rimsky Theater At Landmark On Main StreetPort Washington

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Sunday Oct. 26

lif-calendar-Uncle-Vlad’s-Pumpkin-Patch-2025-10

11 am

Uncle Vlad’s Pumpkin Patch

Ages: 3 – 12
Attractions
Family
Halloween

Long Island Children’s MuseumGarden City

lif-calendar-Uncle-Vlad’s-Pumpkin-Patch-2025-10

1 pm

Uncle Vlad’s Pumpkin Patch

Ages: 3 – 12
Attractions
Family
Halloween

Long Island Children’s MuseumGarden City

2 pm

Chicka Chicka Boom Boom: The Musical

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Music
Theater

Tilles Center for the Performing ArtsBrookville

Monday Oct. 27

7 – 11 pm

Gateway’s Haunted Playhouse

The Gateway PACSCBellport

Tuesday Oct. 28

7 – 11 pm

Gateway’s Haunted Playhouse

The Gateway PACSCBellport

Friday Nov. 7

social-media-generic-300×186

7:30 – 9:30 pm

“The Minutes” at Playcrafters Theatre Company

Theater

Christ Episcopal ChurchBellport

Saturday Nov. 8

Nov 8 La Boheme

1 – 5 pm

THE MET: LIVE IN HD—LA BOHÈME

Theater

Guild HallEast Hampton

Friday Nov. 14

Mrs. Warren’s Profession

7 – 9 pm

NATIONAL THEATRE LIVE: MRS. WARREN’S PROFESSION

Theater

Guild HallEast Hampton

Saturday Nov. 22

Arabella

1 – 5:30 pm

THE MET: LIVE IN HD—ARABELLA

Theater

Guild HallEast Hampton

+ Export Events

More from Around Long Island

A federal judge denied the Town of Oyster Bay's request to postpone its trial date in its legal battle with the Muslims on Long Island.

Long Island Press

Judge denies Town of Oyster Bay’s motion to postpone trial date in suit with Muslims on Long Island

FILE PHOTO: Jennifer Lopez reacts on stage during the 2025 American Music Awards, in Las Vegas, Nevada, U.S., May 26, 2025. REUTERS/Mario Anzuoni/File Photo

Bennifer Reunited for ‘Kiss of the Spider Woman’ Festival Screening

Glass House Boca Raton

Behind the Hedges

Glass House Boca Raton Lists Luxury Corner Residence 23

NYC Mayor's Race candidates Andrew Cuomo, Zohran Mamdani and Curtis Sliwa

NYC Mayor’s Race: Mamdani tops 50% in likely voter poll, widening lead over Cuomo, Sliwa