All the Best Long Island Theater Shows, Musicals and More

Theater shows on Long Island

Find events from Sep 30 to Jan 1 in your neighborhood

On or off Broadway theater shows, listings of plays, musicals, opera, performance art, and so much more

Post an Event

Thursday Oct. 23, 2025

b&j2025

8 – 10 pm

BENNY & THE JETTS

BACCA Arts CenterLindenhurst

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Friday Oct. 24

11 am – 8 pm

Tabernacle Fair

Ages: All
Community
Expo
Family

MahanaimHuntington

Oct 24 Inter Alia

7 – 9 pm

NATIONAL THEATRE LIVE: INTER ALIA

Theater

Guild HallEast Hampton

Revised 9.4.25 Website Two Noble Kinsmen Pic (1160 x 613 px)

8 – 10:30 pm

Two Noble Kinsman – Hofstra University 77th Annual Shakespeare Festival

Theater

Hofstra University, Toni and Martin Sosnoff Theater, John Cranford Adams PlayhouseHempstead

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Saturday Oct. 25

lif-calendar-Uncle-Vlad’s-Pumpkin-Patch-2025-10

11 am

Uncle Vlad’s Pumpkin Patch

Ages: 3 – 12
Attractions
Family
Halloween

Long Island Children’s MuseumGarden City

11 am – 8 pm

Tabernacle Fair

Ages: All
Community
Expo
Family

MahanaimHuntington

lif-calendar-Uncle-Vlad’s-Pumpkin-Patch-2025-10

1 pm

Uncle Vlad’s Pumpkin Patch

Ages: 3 – 12
Attractions
Family
Halloween

Long Island Children’s MuseumGarden City

3 – 5 pm

Diwali Celebration

Jeanne Rimsky Theater At Landmark On Main StreetPort Washington

Revised 9.4.25 Website Two Noble Kinsmen Pic (1160 x 613 px)

8 – 10:30 pm

Two Noble Kinsman – Hofstra University 77th Annual Shakespeare Festival

Theater

Hofstra University, Toni and Martin Sosnoff Theater, John Cranford Adams PlayhouseHempstead

HTDS horizontal banner

8 – 9:30 pm

History That Doesn’t Suck

Westhampton Beach Performing Arts CenterWesthampton Beach

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Sunday Oct. 26

lif-calendar-Uncle-Vlad’s-Pumpkin-Patch-2025-10

11 am

Uncle Vlad’s Pumpkin Patch

Ages: 3 – 12
Attractions
Family
Halloween

Long Island Children’s MuseumGarden City

11 am – 8 pm

Tabernacle Fair

Ages: All
Community
Expo
Family

MahanaimHuntington

lif-calendar-Uncle-Vlad’s-Pumpkin-Patch-2025-10

1 pm

Uncle Vlad’s Pumpkin Patch

Ages: 3 – 12
Attractions
Family
Halloween

Long Island Children’s MuseumGarden City

2 pm

Chicka Chicka Boom Boom: The Musical

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Music
Theater

Tilles Center for the Performing ArtsBrookville

Revised 9.4.25 Website Two Noble Kinsmen Pic (1160 x 613 px)

2 – 4:30 pm

Two Noble Kinsman – Hofstra University 77th Annual Shakespeare Festival

Theater

Hofstra University, Toni and Martin Sosnoff Theater, John Cranford Adams PlayhouseHempstead

3:15 pm

Halloween HARRY HOUDINI Tribute Live

Ages: 5 and up
Family
Festivals
Free

Rolling River Day CampEast Rockaway

5:15 pm

Halloween HARRY HOUDINI Tribute Live

Ages: 5 and up
Family
Festivals
Free

Rolling River Day CampEast Rockaway

7:30 pm

Halloween HARRY HOUDINI Tribute Live

Ages: 5 and up
Family
Festivals
Free

Rolling River Day CampEast Rockaway

Monday Oct. 27

7 – 11 pm

Gateway’s Haunted Playhouse

The Gateway PACSCBellport

Tuesday Oct. 28

7 – 11 pm

Gateway’s Haunted Playhouse

The Gateway PACSCBellport

Wednesday Oct. 29

StellabyStarlight2025

6:30 – 9:30 pm

Stella by Starlight, honoring Alan Cumming, Matthew Modine, Vladimir Duthiers + featuring Rosie Perez, Eric Stoltz and more

The Lighthouse, New York, NYNew York, NY

Thursday Oct. 30

what-fools-midsummer-nights-dream

8 – 9 pm

What Fools! A 1-Hour Version of A Midsummer Night’s Dream – Part of Hofstra University’s 77th Annual Shakespeare Festival

Theater

Hofstra University Joan and Donald Schaeffer Black Box TheaterHempstead

Friday Oct. 31

Revised 9.4.25 Website Two Noble Kinsmen Pic (1160 x 613 px)

8 – 10:30 pm

Two Noble Kinsman – Hofstra University 77th Annual Shakespeare Festival

Theater

Hofstra University, Toni and Martin Sosnoff Theater, John Cranford Adams PlayhouseHempstead

Saturday Nov. 1

Revised 9.4.25 Website Two Noble Kinsmen Pic (1160 x 613 px)

8 – 10:30 pm

Two Noble Kinsman – Hofstra University 77th Annual Shakespeare Festival

Theater

Hofstra University, Toni and Martin Sosnoff Theater, John Cranford Adams PlayhouseHempstead

Sunday Nov. 2

Revised 9.4.25 Website Two Noble Kinsmen Pic (1160 x 613 px)

2 – 4:30 pm

Two Noble Kinsman – Hofstra University 77th Annual Shakespeare Festival

Theater

Hofstra University, Toni and Martin Sosnoff Theater, John Cranford Adams PlayhouseHempstead

Friday Nov. 7

social-media-generic-300×186

7:30 – 9:30 pm

“The Minutes” at Playcrafters Theatre Company

Theater

Christ Episcopal ChurchBellport

Saturday Nov. 8

6b8c44_424a38feb81f4ca2956f027cdbff5b44~mv2

2 am – 8 pm

Five Lesbians Eating Quiche

BACCA Arts CenterLindenhurst

Nov 8 La Boheme

1 – 5 pm

THE MET: LIVE IN HD—LA BOHÈME

Theater

Guild HallEast Hampton

Friday Nov. 14

Mrs. Warren’s Profession

7 – 9 pm

NATIONAL THEATRE LIVE: MRS. WARREN’S PROFESSION

Theater

Guild HallEast Hampton

+ Export Events

More from Around Long Island

DSCN0008_82a156

Long Island Press

Election Guide 2025: Nassau County Legislature District 6 candidate Debra S. Mulé, Dem.

Richard Abbott

Richard Abbott of Jamesport Remembered as Bright Light

East Hampton Village, Georgica Pond

Behind the Hedges

East Hampton Waterfront Estate Lists for $5.9 Million

54856855776_8591ed92f2_4k

Op-Ed | A more accessible transit system is taking shape for all New Yorkers