All the Best Long Island Theater Shows, Musicals and More

Theater shows on Long Island

Find upcoming events in your neighborhood

On or off Broadway theater shows, listings of plays, musicals, opera, performance art, and so much more

Post an Event

Saturday Jan. 17, 2026

8 – 10 pm

The Play Group Theatre’s “She Loves Me”

Ages: 13 and up
Family
Theater

The Play Group TheatreWhite Plains

Sunday Jan. 18

All day

PhysFest NYC – Physical Theater Family Shows & Free Kids Workshops

Ages: All
Comedy
Family
Theater

Stella Adler Center for the ArtsFinancial District

_FLYER_MLK 2025, web, photo credit Winston Williams-Brooklyn Children’s Museum-002

10 am – 5 pm

Celebrate Martin Luther King Jr.

Ages: 12 and under
Art
Attractions
Family

Brooklyn Children’s MuseumBrooklyn

Elephant.0543.2

11 am – noon

Elephant & Piggie’s “We Are In A Play!”

Ages: 3 – 8
Books & Readings
Family
Music

Atlantic Stage 2Chelsea

11 am

Pinkalicious The Musical

Ages: 5 – 8
Family
Theater

Cm Performing Arts CenterOakdale

frt-300dpi-no kids

Noon – 1 pm

Theatresports: Family Improv

Ages: 3 – 12
Comedy
Family
Theater

The Gallery PlayersBrooklyn

hero-303×172

Noon – 10 pm

PhysFest – NYC’s Only Physical Theater Festival Returns!

Ages: All
Comedy
Dance
Family

Stella Adler Center for the ArtsFiDi

5076a03b-0521-4903-aed2-f148cb8dfb7f_TABLET_LANDSCAPE_LARGE_16_9-dWJUqX.tmp_

Noon

Disney On Ice presents Mickey’s Search Party

Ages: All
Family
Theater

UBS ArenaElmont

bf-calendar-The-Tortoise-&-the-Hare-2025-01

12:30 pm

The Tortoise & the Hare

Ages: All
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

2 – 4 pm

The Play Group Theatre’s “She Loves Me”

Ages: 13 and up
Family
Theater

The Play Group TheatreWhite Plains

bf-calendar-The-Tortoise-&-the-Hare-2025-01

2:30 pm

The Tortoise & the Hare

Ages: All
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

GoldstarTodayTix2_480_720

3 – 5 pm

ApocaLIPSTICK

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

shelter_180_278

3 – 5 pm

Shelter In Place

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

5076a03b-0521-4903-aed2-f148cb8dfb7f_TABLET_LANDSCAPE_LARGE_16_9-dWJUqX.tmp_

4 pm

Disney On Ice presents Mickey’s Search Party

Ages: All
Family
Theater

UBS ArenaElmont

Elephant.0543.2

4 – 5 pm

Elephant & Piggie’s “We Are In A Play!”

Ages: 3 – 8
Books & Readings
Family
Music

Atlantic Stage 2Chelsea

6 – 8 pm

Secrets: Immersive Play

Theater

Secrets BarWest Village

Screen Shot 2025-12-11 at 3.38.15 PM

7:30 – 9:30 pm

ROOM 204 at Walker Hotel Greenwich Village

Theater

Walker Hotel Greenwich VillageGreenwich Village

Monday Jan. 19

_FLYER_MLK 2025, web, photo credit Winston Williams-Brooklyn Children’s Museum-002

10 am – 5 pm

Celebrate Martin Luther King Jr.

Ages: 12 and under
Art
Attractions
Family

Brooklyn Children’s MuseumBrooklyn

5076a03b-0521-4903-aed2-f148cb8dfb7f_TABLET_LANDSCAPE_LARGE_16_9-dWJUqX.tmp_

Noon

Disney On Ice presents Mickey’s Search Party

Ages: All
Family
Theater

UBS ArenaElmont

Screen Shot 2025-12-11 at 3.38.15 PM

7:30 – 9:30 pm

ROOM 204 at Walker Hotel Greenwich Village

Theater

Walker Hotel Greenwich VillageGreenwich Village

Tuesday Jan. 20

7 – 8:30 pm

Sketches from the Edge of Flamenco

Dance
Film

Rodney’s Comedy ClubEastside

Wednesday Jan. 21

9:30 – 11 pm

Two Lesbians Walk into A Bar…

Caveat NYCManhattan

Thursday Jan. 22

shelter_180_278

3 – 5 pm

Shelter In Place

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

6 – 8 pm

Secrets: Immersive Play

Theater

Secrets BarWest Village

shelter_180_278

7 – 9 pm

Shelter In Place

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

Friday Jan. 23

6 – 8 pm

Secrets: Immersive Play

Theater

Secrets BarWest Village

shelter_180_278

7 – 9 pm

Shelter In Place

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

Carmines_Take2_EventbriteImage

7:30 – 9:30 pm

Speakeasy, Die Softly: Immersive Murder Mystery Dinner Theater at Carmine’s

Carmine’s Italian Restaurant – Times SquareNew York City

8:30 – 10 pm

UG! Comedy Show

One and OneEast Village

Saturday Jan. 24

Elephant.0543.2

11 am – noon

Elephant & Piggie’s “We Are In A Play!”

Ages: 3 – 8
Books & Readings
Family
Music

Atlantic Stage 2Chelsea

+ Export Events

More from Around Long Island

Bobby is one of nine adoptable dogs and cats who want to start the new year right — in a new, loving home.

Long Island Press

9 adoptable rescue pets who want a new home for the new year

Rabbi Leibel, Steve Goldberg

New Years Shabbat in East Hampton

Roundtable, Long Island, 2026

Behind the Hedges

Evolution, Not a Reset: Long Island Agents Forecast the 2026 Market

Luigi Mangione appears in federal court for murder of insurance executive, in New York City

Luigi Mangione’s lawyers fight to pick apart federal case that could carry death penalty