All the Best Long Island Theater Shows, Musicals and More

Theater shows on Long Island

Find upcoming events in your neighborhood

On or off Broadway theater shows, listings of plays, musicals, opera, performance art, and so much more

Post an Event

Thursday Jan. 15, 2026

hero-303×172

Noon – 10 pm

PhysFest – NYC’s Only Physical Theater Festival Returns!

Ages: All
Comedy
Dance
Family

Stella Adler Center for the ArtsFiDi

shelter_180_278

3 – 5 pm

Shelter In Place

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

6 – 8 pm

Secrets: Immersive Play

Theater

Secrets BarWest Village

shelter_180_278

7 – 9 pm

Shelter In Place

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

5076a03b-0521-4903-aed2-f148cb8dfb7f_TABLET_LANDSCAPE_LARGE_16_9-dWJUqX.tmp_

7 – 10 pm

Disney On Ice presents Mickey’s Search Party

Ages: All
Family
Theater

UBS ArenaElmont

8 – 10 pm

Always Young The Musical

Theater

Theater for the New CityEast Village

Friday Jan. 16

All day

PhysFest NYC – Physical Theater Family Shows & Free Kids Workshops

Ages: All
Comedy
Family
Theater

Stella Adler Center for the ArtsFinancial District

hero-303×172

Noon – 10 pm

PhysFest – NYC’s Only Physical Theater Festival Returns!

Ages: All
Comedy
Dance
Family

Stella Adler Center for the ArtsFiDi

6 – 8 pm

Secrets: Immersive Play

Theater

Secrets BarWest Village

shelter_180_278

7 – 9 pm

Shelter In Place

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

5076a03b-0521-4903-aed2-f148cb8dfb7f_TABLET_LANDSCAPE_LARGE_16_9-dWJUqX.tmp_

7 – 10 pm

Disney On Ice presents Mickey’s Search Party

Ages: All
Family
Theater

UBS ArenaElmont

Carmines_Take2_EventbriteImage

7:30 – 9:30 pm

Speakeasy, Die Softly: Immersive Murder Mystery Dinner Theater at Carmine’s

Carmine’s Italian Restaurant – Times SquareNew York City

8:30 – 10 pm

UG! Comedy Show

One and OneEast Village

Saturday Jan. 17

All day

PhysFest NYC – Physical Theater Family Shows & Free Kids Workshops

Ages: All
Comedy
Family
Theater

Stella Adler Center for the ArtsFinancial District

Elephant.0543.2

11 am – noon

Elephant & Piggie’s “We Are In A Play!”

Ages: 3 – 8
Books & Readings
Family
Music

Atlantic Stage 2Chelsea

5076a03b-0521-4903-aed2-f148cb8dfb7f_TABLET_LANDSCAPE_LARGE_16_9-dWJUqX.tmp_

11 am

Disney On Ice presents Mickey’s Search Party

Ages: All
Family
Theater

UBS ArenaElmont

hero-303×172

Noon – 10 pm

PhysFest – NYC’s Only Physical Theater Festival Returns!

Ages: All
Comedy
Dance
Family

Stella Adler Center for the ArtsFiDi

bf-calendar-The-Tortoise-&-the-Hare-2025-01

12:30 pm

The Tortoise & the Hare

Ages: All
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

Broadway Magic Hour with Jim Vines and Carl Mercurio

2 – 3 pm

Broadway Magic Hour

Ages: 5 and up
Comedy
Family
Theater

Broadway Comedy Clubnew york

princess_pea_3to1

2 – 3 pm

The Princess and the Pea

Ages: All
Family
Theater

Galli Theater NYTribeca

bf-calendar-The-Tortoise-&-the-Hare-2025-01

2:30 pm

The Tortoise & the Hare

Ages: All
Family
Theater

Puppetworks IncBrooklyn

5076a03b-0521-4903-aed2-f148cb8dfb7f_TABLET_LANDSCAPE_LARGE_16_9-dWJUqX.tmp_

3 pm

Disney On Ice presents Mickey’s Search Party

Ages: All
Family
Theater

UBS ArenaElmont

Elephant.0543.2

4 – 5 pm

Elephant & Piggie’s “We Are In A Play!”

Ages: 3 – 8
Books & Readings
Family
Music

Atlantic Stage 2Chelsea

Carmines_Take2_EventbriteImage

4:30 – 6:30 pm

Speakeasy, Die Softly: Immersive Murder Mystery Dinner Theater at Carmine’s

Carmine’s Italian Restaurant – Times SquareNew York City

The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show

6 – 9 pm

The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show

The Mansion at Glen CoveGlen Cove

6 – 8 pm

Secrets: Immersive Play

Theater

Secrets BarWest Village

shelter_180_278

7 – 9 pm

Shelter In Place

Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

Isaac Stern Auditorium / Ronald O. Perelman Stage

7 – 9:30 pm

The Georgian National Ballet Sukhishvili

Dance
LGBTQ+

Carnegie Hall, Stern Auditorium/Perelman StageMidtown Manhattan

5076a03b-0521-4903-aed2-f148cb8dfb7f_TABLET_LANDSCAPE_LARGE_16_9-dWJUqX.tmp_

7 – 10 pm

Disney On Ice presents Mickey’s Search Party

Ages: All
Family
Theater

UBS ArenaElmont

8 – 10 pm

The Play Group Theatre’s “She Loves Me”

Ages: 13 and up
Family
Theater

The Play Group TheatreWhite Plains

Carmines_Take2_EventbriteImage

8 – 10 pm

Speakeasy, Die Softly: Immersive Murder Mystery Dinner Theater at Carmine’s

Carmine’s Italian Restaurant – Times SquareNew York City

+ Export Events

More from Around Long Island

Jove Equities CEO David Calone gives his insight on how AI and biotech will continue to impact Long Island.

Long Island Press

AI, biotech and Long Island’s economic future

DansSterbeCrop

Susan Sterber Discusses Painting Snow with Watercolor

Harry Macklowe, East Hampton, Georgica Pond

Behind the Hedges

Harry Macklowe’s Georgica Pond Estate Returns to Market With C of O Path Resolved

A train with subway conductor in Queens

Subway conductor assaulted on A train in Queens in early-morning attack: cops