All the Best Long Island Theater Shows, Musicals and More

Theater shows on Long Island

Find events happening tomorrow in your neighborhood

On or off Broadway theater shows, listings of plays, musicals, opera, performance art, and so much more

Post an Event

Friday Oct. 17, 2025

poster closeup

7 am – 10 pm

I Scream Theater

Comedy
Dance

The RATBrooklyn

Lines Verses Lyrics a Meeting of River and Sky Celebrating Langston Hughes and Stevie Wonder FLIER7d Resized 5X7 in Photoshop2 ARTWORK By Nikki Williams September 27 2025

6 – 8:30 pm

“Lines Verses Lyrics: Where River and Sky Meet” – Man Men in the Arts Celebrate Black Poetry Day

Free
Theater

ARC A. Philip Randolph AOCHarlem

Lines Verses Lyrics a Meeting of River and Sky Celebrating Langston Hughes and Stevie Wonder FLIER7d Resized 5X7 in Photoshop2 ARTWORK By Nikki Williams September 27 2025

6 – 8:30 pm

“Lines Verses Lyrics: Where River and Sky Meet” – Black Men in the Arts Celebrate Black Poetry Day

ARC A. Philip Randolph AOCHarlem

7 pm

The Haunt at Wildcliff Mansion

Ages: 9 and up
Family
Halloween
Holiday

Hudson Park Children’s GreenhouseNew Rochelle

7 – 9 pm

Blood Orange, a new play by Abigail Duclos

Theater

Jeffrey and Paula Gural Theatre @ A.R.T./New York TheatresMidtown

YearbookC

7 – 9 pm

you are seen (Murmuration Theatre Co @ The Makers’ Space)

Makers’ SpaceBrooklyn

boo

7 – 8 pm

BOO! The Players Theatre Short Play Festival

The Players TheatreNew York City

(un)conditional cast-photo by Russ Rowland-print

7 – 8:30 pm

(un)conditional

Theater

SOHO PLAYHOUSESoho

117388-The Harlem Gospel Travelers Soul Revival Residency

7 – 8:30 pm

The Harlem Gospel Travelers “Soul Revival” Residency

Groove

La monja alférez at Teatro Círculo

7 pm

LA MONJA ALFÉREZ by Juan Ruiz de Alarcón in October 2025 at Teatro Círculo

Art
Theater

Teatro CírculoNew York City

7 – 8:30 pm

Sleepy Hollow the Musical

Ages: 9 and up
Family
Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

72Artwork – TrumanVSIsrael copy

7:30 – 9 pm

Truman vs. Israel: Abzug and the Undressing of Truman

Theater

Theater at St. ClementsTheater District

Screenshot

7:30 – 10 pm

“She Ate” The Ultimate Drag Dinner Show at Branded Saloon

Art
Comedy

Branded SaloonBrooklyn

Screenshot

7:30 – 9:30 pm

Italian American Reconciliation

Theater

The Flea TheaterTribeca

Full Company 2

7:30 – 9 pm

Helen in her Homeland: a reflection in three rooms by Alexandra Haddad

Theater

748 Manhattan AveGreenpoint

Screenshot

7:30 – 9:30 pm

Playwrights’ Theatre of East Hampton at LTV Studios Presents ‘Be My Baby’

Theater

LTV StudiosWainscott

Processed with VSCO with e2 preset

7:30 – 9 pm

TARRYTOWN – The legend of Sleepy Hollow, a new musical

the cell theatreChelsea

8:30 – 10 pm

UG! Comedy Show

One and OneEast Village

72-2025 Artwork – Queer Spooky Shorts copy 2

9 pm

Queer Spooky Shorts 2025

Free
LGBTQ+

The Flea TheaterTriBeCa

Spirits_FeverImage_1080x1080_FINAL

10 – 11:30 pm

Spirits at Carmine’s

Carmine’s Italian Restaurant – Times SquareNew York City

+ Export Events

More from Around Long Island

Locust Valley Superintendent Kristen Turnow says the district continues to strive to enhance its performance.

Long Island Press

Locust Valley High School ranks No. 232 in state, resident says IB program is at fault

IDF soldier and Plainview native Omer Neutra was killed in the Oct. 7, 2023 Hamas terrorist attacks on Israel.

The Hostages Are Home: A Letter from the Publishers

Joe Vella, owner of All Island Handyman and Construction

Behind the Hedges

Renovation Renaissance: Joe Vella Is Leaving His Imprint on the Hamptons

"SPOTLIGHT! The Dorothy Dandridge Musical" is holding industry readings next week.

‘SPOTLIGHT! The Dorothy Dandridge Musical’ — A resurrection of radiance, resistance, and the fire of forgotten glory