All the Best Long Island Theater Shows, Musicals and More

Theater shows on Long Island

Find events happening this weekend in your neighborhood

On or off Broadway theater shows, listings of plays, musicals, opera, performance art, and so much more

Post an Event

Thursday Oct. 23, 2025

b&j2025

8 – 10 pm

BENNY & THE JETTS

BACCA Arts CenterLindenhurst

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Friday Oct. 24

11 am – 8 pm

Tabernacle Fair

Ages: All
Community
Expo
Family

MahanaimHuntington

Oct 24 Inter Alia

7 – 9 pm

NATIONAL THEATRE LIVE: INTER ALIA

Theater

Guild HallEast Hampton

Revised 9.4.25 Website Two Noble Kinsmen Pic (1160 x 613 px)

8 – 10:30 pm

Two Noble Kinsman – Hofstra University 77th Annual Shakespeare Festival

Theater

Hofstra University, Toni and Martin Sosnoff Theater, John Cranford Adams PlayhouseHempstead

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Saturday Oct. 25

lif-calendar-Uncle-Vlad’s-Pumpkin-Patch-2025-10

11 am

Uncle Vlad’s Pumpkin Patch

Ages: 3 – 12
Attractions
Family
Halloween

Long Island Children’s MuseumGarden City

11 am – 8 pm

Tabernacle Fair

Ages: All
Community
Expo
Family

MahanaimHuntington

lif-calendar-Uncle-Vlad’s-Pumpkin-Patch-2025-10

1 pm

Uncle Vlad’s Pumpkin Patch

Ages: 3 – 12
Attractions
Family
Halloween

Long Island Children’s MuseumGarden City

3 – 5 pm

Diwali Celebration

Jeanne Rimsky Theater At Landmark On Main StreetPort Washington

Revised 9.4.25 Website Two Noble Kinsmen Pic (1160 x 613 px)

8 – 10:30 pm

Two Noble Kinsman – Hofstra University 77th Annual Shakespeare Festival

Theater

Hofstra University, Toni and Martin Sosnoff Theater, John Cranford Adams PlayhouseHempstead

HTDS horizontal banner

8 – 9:30 pm

History That Doesn’t Suck

Westhampton Beach Performing Arts CenterWesthampton Beach

Screenshot_20251014_170551_Google(2)(1)

8:30 – 11 pm

The Rocky Horror Pictures Show at Sparkle on Stage

Sparkle on StageFREEPORT

Sunday Oct. 26

lif-calendar-Uncle-Vlad’s-Pumpkin-Patch-2025-10

11 am

Uncle Vlad’s Pumpkin Patch

Ages: 3 – 12
Attractions
Family
Halloween

Long Island Children’s MuseumGarden City

11 am – 8 pm

Tabernacle Fair

Ages: All
Community
Expo
Family

MahanaimHuntington

lif-calendar-Uncle-Vlad’s-Pumpkin-Patch-2025-10

1 pm

Uncle Vlad’s Pumpkin Patch

Ages: 3 – 12
Attractions
Family
Halloween

Long Island Children’s MuseumGarden City

2 pm

Chicka Chicka Boom Boom: The Musical

Ages: 3 – 8
Family
Music
Theater

Tilles Center for the Performing ArtsBrookville

Revised 9.4.25 Website Two Noble Kinsmen Pic (1160 x 613 px)

2 – 4:30 pm

Two Noble Kinsman – Hofstra University 77th Annual Shakespeare Festival

Theater

Hofstra University, Toni and Martin Sosnoff Theater, John Cranford Adams PlayhouseHempstead

3:15 pm

Halloween HARRY HOUDINI Tribute Live

Ages: 5 and up
Family
Festivals
Free

Rolling River Day CampEast Rockaway

5:15 pm

Halloween HARRY HOUDINI Tribute Live

Ages: 5 and up
Family
Festivals
Free

Rolling River Day CampEast Rockaway

7:30 pm

Halloween HARRY HOUDINI Tribute Live

Ages: 5 and up
Family
Festivals
Free

Rolling River Day CampEast Rockaway

Monday Oct. 27

7 – 11 pm

Gateway’s Haunted Playhouse

The Gateway PACSCBellport

Tuesday Oct. 28

7 – 11 pm

Gateway’s Haunted Playhouse

The Gateway PACSCBellport

Wednesday Oct. 29

StellabyStarlight2025

6:30 – 9:30 pm

Stella by Starlight, honoring Alan Cumming, Matthew Modine, Vladimir Duthiers + featuring Rosie Perez, Eric Stoltz and more

The Lighthouse, New York, NYNew York, NY

Thursday Oct. 30

what-fools-midsummer-nights-dream

8 – 9 pm

What Fools! A 1-Hour Version of A Midsummer Night’s Dream – Part of Hofstra University’s 77th Annual Shakespeare Festival

Theater

Hofstra University Joan and Donald Schaeffer Black Box TheaterHempstead

Friday Oct. 31

Revised 9.4.25 Website Two Noble Kinsmen Pic (1160 x 613 px)

8 – 10:30 pm

Two Noble Kinsman – Hofstra University 77th Annual Shakespeare Festival

Theater

Hofstra University, Toni and Martin Sosnoff Theater, John Cranford Adams PlayhouseHempstead

Saturday Nov. 1

Revised 9.4.25 Website Two Noble Kinsmen Pic (1160 x 613 px)

8 – 10:30 pm

Two Noble Kinsman – Hofstra University 77th Annual Shakespeare Festival

Theater

Hofstra University, Toni and Martin Sosnoff Theater, John Cranford Adams PlayhouseHempstead

Sunday Nov. 2

Revised 9.4.25 Website Two Noble Kinsmen Pic (1160 x 613 px)

2 – 4:30 pm

Two Noble Kinsman – Hofstra University 77th Annual Shakespeare Festival

Theater

Hofstra University, Toni and Martin Sosnoff Theater, John Cranford Adams PlayhouseHempstead

Friday Nov. 7

social-media-generic-300×186

7:30 – 9:30 pm

“The Minutes” at Playcrafters Theatre Company

Theater

Christ Episcopal ChurchBellport

Saturday Nov. 8

6b8c44_424a38feb81f4ca2956f027cdbff5b44~mv2

2 am – 8 pm

Five Lesbians Eating Quiche

BACCA Arts CenterLindenhurst

Nov 8 La Boheme

1 – 5 pm

THE MET: LIVE IN HD—LA BOHÈME

Theater

Guild HallEast Hampton

Friday Nov. 14

Mrs. Warren’s Profession

7 – 9 pm

NATIONAL THEATRE LIVE: MRS. WARREN’S PROFESSION

Theater

Guild HallEast Hampton

+ Export Events

More from Around Long Island

Tootsie Roll is one of this week's adoptable dogs looking for their forever home!

Long Island Press

14 adoptable rescues to cuddle up with this spooky season

Kelly Ripa and Mark Consuelos at the Time 100 Gala 2024

Kelly Ripa & Mark Consuelos Spar on Air Over ‘Airport Divorce’

East Hampton Village, Georgica Pond

Behind the Hedges

East Hampton Waterfront Estate Lists for $5.9 Million

IMG_3342 copy

NYC Mayor’s Race: Mamdani rails against Islamophobia in emotional speech; Cuomo charges Dem nominee is ‘playing victim’