All the Best Long Island Theater Shows, Musicals and More

Theater shows on Long Island

Find events happening tomorrow in your neighborhood

On or off Broadway theater shows, listings of plays, musicals, opera, performance art, and so much more

Post an Event

Wednesday Oct. 29, 2025

ANewBrain_26141e

7:30 am – 9:30 pm

St Bart’s Players: A New Brain

Theater

72Artwork – TrumanVSIsrael copy

3 – 4:30 pm

Truman vs. Israel: Abzug and the Undressing of Truman

Theater

Theater at St. ClementsTheater District

StellabyStarlight2025

6:30 – 9:30 pm

Stella by Starlight, honoring Alan Cumming, Matthew Modine, Vladimir Duthiers + featuring Rosie Perez, Eric Stoltz and more

The Lighthouse, New York, NYNew York, NY

PygKeyArt_SQUARE_5102d5

7 pm

Bernard Shaw’s Pygmalion

Theater

72Artwork – TrumanVSIsrael copy

7:30 – 9 pm

Truman vs. Israel: Abzug and the Undressing of Truman

Theater

Theater at St. ClementsTheater District

Judd Apatow Comedy Nerd

7:30 – 9 pm

Judd Apatow, Comedy Nerd

Peter Norton Symphony SpaceUpper West Side

ANewBrain

7:30 – 10 pm

St Bart’s Players: A New Brain

Theater

Y14Lower East Side

72-Sally-Spectre-The-Musical-Postcard copy

8 – 9:30 pm

Sally Spectre the Musical

30th Street TheaterChelsea

8 – 10 pm

Musical Mystery Theatre with The Mystery Players

Room 52Midtown

+ Export Events

More from Around Long Island

North Hempstead appealed the court's ruling in favor of the Hillside Islamic Center.

Long Island Press

North Hempstead appeals Islamic center expansion decision

Billy Joel performs at Allegiant Stadium on November 09, 2024 in Las Vegas, Nevada. (Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images)

Billy Joel Exhibit Comes to an End After Nearly 2 Years at LIMEHOF

East Hampton, Northwest Woods

Behind the Hedges

Noted Designer’s Retreat in East Hampton’s Northwest Woods

dog voting

Judicial elections: What to know for 2025