All the Best Long Island Theater Shows, Musicals and More

Theater shows on Long Island

Find events happening tomorrow in your neighborhood

On or off Broadway theater shows, listings of plays, musicals, opera, performance art, and so much more

Post an Event

Friday Oct. 24, 2025

Round the Block Image

5 – 6 pm

THEATERLAB’S ROUND THE BLOCK!™ FREE COMMUNITY PROGRAMMING FOR THE GARMENT DISTRICT

520 8th AvenueGarment District

Square

6 – 9 pm

“NOT Just Sinatra” with Steven Maglio & his Big Band Orchestra

The Cutting Room NYCManhattan

CLS MARKETING 10

6 – 8 pm

Cirque Le Swing

SWING 46 RESTAURANT AND LOUNGENew York City, NY

7 – 9 pm

Blood Orange, a new play by Abigail Duclos

Theater

Jeffrey and Paula Gural Theatre @ A.R.T./New York TheatresMidtown

PygKeyArt_SQUARE_5102d5

7 pm

Bernard Shaw’s Pygmalion

Theater

(un)conditional cast-photo by Russ Rowland-print

7 – 8:30 pm

(un)conditional

Theater

SOHO PLAYHOUSESoho

7 – 8:30 pm

Sleepy Hollow the Musical

Ages: 9 and up
Family
Theater

The Players TheatreNew York City

Screenshot

7 – 9 pm

TALE: NYC’s Finest Storytelling

The Red RoomLES

Elliot-Reed_PAM-21_and_Over_Christopher_Wormald_Photography_119 Large

7 – 9 pm

Offerings: GENT PTP, Julia Antinozzi, Elliot Reed

Art
Dance

Church of St. Mary the VirginTimes Square

7_2b91a4

7 – 11:30 pm

Death in the Disco – Competitive Murder Mystery Party

Theater

Torch & Crown Brewing CompanySoho

UNDER THE RAINBOW AD Gay City News (1080 x 1080 px) (1000 x 700 px) (1)

7 – 8 pm

Under the Rainbow @ The United Solo Festival

Theatre Row, 410 W 42nd Street, NY, NYHell’s Kitchen

72Artwork – TrumanVSIsrael copy

7:30 – 9 pm

Truman vs. Israel: Abzug and the Undressing of Truman

Theater

Theater at St. ClementsTheater District

Screenshot

7:30 – 9:30 pm

Italian American Reconciliation

Theater

The Flea TheaterTribeca

Full Company 2

7:30 – 9 pm

Helen in her Homeland: a reflection in three rooms by Alexandra Haddad

Theater

748 Manhattan AveGreenpoint

Processed with VSCO with e2 preset

7:30 – 9 pm

TARRYTOWN – The legend of Sleepy Hollow, a new musical

the cell theatreChelsea

Screenshot 2025-09-25 at 3.12.40 PM

7:30 – 9:30 pm

As You Like It

Free
Theater

151 Bank Street

World Builders_Inner Poster_IG copy

7:30 – 9 pm

Two Imaginary Worlds Collide in Johnna Adams’ “World Builders”

Theater

124 Bank Street Theater

72-Sally-Spectre-The-Musical-Postcard copy

8 – 9:30 pm

Sally Spectre the Musical

30th Street TheaterChelsea

8:30 – 10 pm

UG! Comedy Show

One and OneEast Village

Spirits_FeverImage_1080x1080_FINAL

10 – 11:30 pm

Spirits at Carmine’s

Carmine’s Italian Restaurant – Times SquareNew York City

+ Export Events

More from Around Long Island

Janine Biscari, vice president of student affairs at Molloy University, with NY Islanders mascot Sparky, at UBS Arena before the New York Islanders' home opener.

Long Island Press

Molloy University, Franklin Square business enter media partnership with Islanders

Sara Topping, Ann Welker, Maria Moore, Jimmy Mack

Westhampton Beach Welcomes Crowds for Annual Fall Festival

Cape Cod, Southampton, Estate Section

Behind the Hedges

Cape Cod Delivers Best Value in Southampton Estate Area

little girl wrapped in Israeli flag

Op-Ed | As the war in Gaza winds down, we must also confront the fact that antisemitism has become the ‘new normal’